The Nature's Gift Dog Food Review: Tested & Evaluated 2023

Wondering what’s the best supermarket dog food for your little one?

No worries! Our team spent months studying Nature's Gift dog food to determine if they are a good choice for our dogs. Together with other experts, we tested it and researched its various aspects.

In this in-depth Nature's Gift dog food review, the results of our examination of this product will be revealed to you, and we also included everything there is to know about this affordable brand. Now you can make an informed decision based on your dog's needs!

Related: The Best Dog Food Australia
Related: How To Choose The Right Dog Food?
Related: How Is Australia’s Dog Food Industry Regulated?
Related: What is AAFCO? The Association of American Feed Control Officials
Related: What Is the Pet Food Industry Association of Australia (PFIAA)?
Related: AAFCO vs PFIAA: Dog Food Standards Comparison Australia
Related: Understanding Guaranteed Analysis Levels in Dog Food
Related: Real Meat vs Meat Meal

Australia's Nature’s Gift Dog Food Reviewed

Taste 4/5

In general, this is a good-tasting option that most dogs love. Since the first ingredient in all recipes is poultry meal, it’s no wonder pooches really like the flavour.

In terms of taste, this dog food can compete with Petzyo. The semi-moist dry food recipes, that feature a softer kibble, are especially good if you have a senior dog that can’t chew on hard things. This also comes in handy if your pup is a mini or toy breed (with a significantly smaller jaw) and needs special kibble.

It's important to notice some owners report their dogs vomited after switching them to this brand. While this could very well be an issue with the food itself, it likely had to do with improper transition times.

As we’ve mentioned before, your dog’s gastrointestinal system needs some time to get accustomed to new foods. This is especially true if you exclusively feed kibble to them. Whenever you’re switching brands, or even if you just bought a new bag of the same food, it’s a good idea to go slow. This means introducing new foods mixed with the old one, and slowly bumping up the proportions until everything is new food.

This is very important, and we recommend that dog owners take note of this practice before giving this dog food to them. Even if your dog loves the taste of this brand, their stomach won't certainly do the same if you're not going to introduce this food slowly.

This method ensures your dog has a better chance to get used to the new food, their tummy won’t suffer and the whole experience will be easier on both of you.

Ingredients 2/5

To understand whether or not this is a good option for your dog, checking the ingredient list is essential. At a glance, it starts well: the first ingredient is animal protein in various forms. As such, several recipes have poultry meal, chicken meal or meat meal at the top of the list. According to the AAFCO, meal protein is;

As such, this is a more concentrated form of plain meat cuts. Of course, its quality depends entirely on the source, but it’s a good base for any dog’s diet.

In contrast, the following top ingredients (that complete the bulk of this food) aren’t as beneficial. After poultry meal and chicken meat we have wholegrain wheat, wholegrain rice, sucrose and potatoes. Let’s examine what that means for your dog’s health:

Looking at the core ingredients in Nature’s Gift, this is a carb-heavy food. With only 24% protein and 8% fat, the bulk of the calories come from starches.

Manufacturers aren’t forced to disclose their carb percentage, but in this case, the main five ingredients are stacked 3:2 carbs to proteins in some recipes. Some flavours go as far as 4:1 carbs to protein, which would make around 75% of the food.

Unlike Eureka and other Australian-made dog food, this is a high-carbohydrate food we don't recommend for dogs needing a low-carb diet.

Because of its very high starch content, we’re taking off 3 stars in this category.

Protein Content 3/5

In comparison to other kibble options available in the market, Nature’s Gift has a modest protein percentage. However, a smaller amount of protein isn’t necessarily bad and is still in line with AAFCO’s recommendations. Officially, dog food should have at least 18% protein. Many dry food recipes claim to have up to 30% crude protein per serving, but this is usually inflated with vegetable proteins.

In the case of Nature’s Gift, this percentage is probably due in large part to actual animal protein. While the added wheat and peas are probably responsible for part of it, meat is still the main ingredient.

As for the protein source itself, dehydrated poultry meal, meat meal and fish meal are the first ingredients in all recipes. This is very good and in general we consider this a decent source of healthy protein.

However, the lower fat content isn’t such good news. Dogs need fat as an energy source and too little can cause nutritional deficiencies. Most pet foods available offer around 10-12% fat, so Nature’s Gift percentage is significantly low for a food that isn’t targeted at weight management.

Because of these shortcomings, we’re taking off 2 stars.

Additives 2/5

Like most other brands, Nature’s Gift has some nice extras, and others we’d rather see disappear. Let’s start with the good ones:

On a positive note, this brand features peas and carrots in most of their recipes. While peas can artificially boost protein percentage, they’re a healthy legume option for many dogs. Carrots on the other hand are a good source of vitamin A and fibre. Other extras like canola oil, chia seeds and flaxseed ensure your pup gets enough Omega-3 and Omega-6 to thrive.

In contrast, this brand also adds sucrose to their dry food recipes. This is concerning since sucrose is a simple sugar (unlike complex carbs like sweet potatoes) that offer very little in terms of nutritional value and are mainly used to increase palatability. The recipes also add phosphoric acid, an additive that is considered safe by the FDA but some studies show it might be dangerous:

Further research is needed to nail down the long-term effects of phosphoric acid consumption, but in the meantime it’s best to avoid ingesting it in larger quantities.

Considering the mentioned information, this brand neither has much nor few additives. We find that its pros and cons are almost equal.

Because of these issues, we’re taking off 3 stars in this category.

Variety 4/5

Although Nature’s Gift recipes aren’t especially numerous, they have significant variety when it comes to texture. Their dry dog food has two distinct options: traditional dry and semi-moist kibble.

Many older dogs enjoy the semi-moist recipe better than regular crunchy kibble. Of course, you can always stick to the traditional recipe if you rely on kibble to clean their teeth. Their dry line has different flavour options including chicken, beef, fish and kangaroo, with or without vegetables which can be compared to famous brands like Petzyo.

This brand also offers a modest range of wet and chilled options. The wet recipes are available in cans or trays and should be consumed within the day of opening. These can be used as the basis of a balanced diet, while the chilled food is meant to be a treat or supplement other meals.

Not a lot of dog food in the Australian market offers these options, and this is one of the things that we like about this brand.

Since there’s plenty of options to choose from, we’re giving Nature’s Gift 4 out of 5 in this category.

Price 4/5

This is a supermarket food, so the price is fairly reasonable. However, we find the packages are very small, especially if you’re trying to feed a large dog or several pups at once.

For example, most of their kibble is only available in bags up to 2.5 kg, with some recipes coming in 5 kg bags. This is enough for a small dog, but you’ll have to buy several bags at once to feed a larger one. If you look for the brand online, you might be able to find some bundle deals to save even more.

When compared with Ziwi Peak, which is one of our top dog food brands in Australia, Nature's Gift is more affordable. However, considering the quality of ingredients and the protein content found in Ziwi Peak, it can be given in small portions, and you can also add them to your dog's raw meal, so you don't have to buy several bags.

Still, the price can be justified by the ingredients. It's recommended if you don't need to buy in bulk, but you can find bundles in stores with a good deal.

Nature’s Gift Puppy Dog Food

After looking at the brand as a whole, it’s important to focus on their puppy options. Since nutrition is so important for younger dogs, we wanted a closer look at their youngster recipes.

Nature’s Gift has only two puppy options: beef and chicken. However, it’s important to notice the chicken option has "meat and meat meal (poultry and beef)" as the first ingredient, meaning that you won’t be able to offer just chicken protein with this food. Both the "chicken" and beef recipe are identical, except for that ingredient.

In general, the composition looks fairly similar to that of the adult recipes: the first ingredient is animal protein, followed by "wholegrain cereals", "vegetables", "cereal meal" and "vegetable meal".

Considering those first five ingredients, this is a very cereal-heavy recipe. Again, while wheat, sorghum, barley and rice can be part of a balanced diet, they shouldn’t be in such a high percentage.

On top of this, as we don’t know what’s included under "vegetables", those can be anything from potatoes to spinach. As mentioned before, we’re wary of blanket terms since it makes it difficult to determine the source of food allergies. Since puppies are especially sensitive, it’s always better when you can be completely sure about what you’re giving them.

This is important to note for us dog owners because we might put our dogs' health at risk by not knowing what is in their food.

Despite these shortcomings, it’s important to notice the puppy recipes are higher in protein (26%) and fats (12%) than their adult recipes. This is perfect to offer a higher caloric intake, much needed by growing pups.

Overall, we like the higher fat content and consider this a reasonably good choice when it comes to supermarket foods.

Don’t Buy If…

This is a good option for many dogs, but you might want to look elsewhere if you:

The Verdict

All things considered, this is one of the best options you can find at a supermarket. However, you’ll find similar ingredients and compositions at a dedicated pet store. If this is all you have access to, it isn’t a bad place to start, especially if you complement your dog’s diet with fresh meats and low-starch veggies.

We recommend that if you decide to buy this product for your dogs, make sure that they don't have any food sensitivities to the ingredients mentioned in this brand.

Want to read more dog food brand reviews? Check out the below:

• Ivory Coat Dog Food Review
• Canidae Dog Food Review
• Advance Dog Food Review
• Supercoat Dog Food Review
• Black Hawk Dog Food Review
• Farmers Market Dog Food Review
• Optimum Dog Food Review
• Applaws Dog Food Review
• Royal Canin Dog Food Review
• Baxters Dog Food Review
• Leaps & Bounds Dog Food Review
• Stay Loyal Dog Food Review
• Pedigree Dog Food Review
• Science Diet Dog Food Review
• Savour Life Dog Food Review
• Scratch Dog Food Review

References

1. "What’s in the Ingredients List?". Association of American Feed Control Officials. Retrieved November 7, 2023. https://www.aafco.org/consumers/understanding-pet-food/whats-in-the-ingredients-list/
2. “What should I feed my dog?”. RSPCA Australia. Retrieved November 7, 2023. https://kb.rspca.org.au/knowledge-base/what-should-i-feed-my-dog/
3. Colie, C. May 19, 2023. "Can Dogs Eat Wheat and Other Grains?". American Kennel Club. Retrieved November 7, 2023. https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/nutrition/can-dogs-eat-wheat/
4. "Phosphoric Acid in Dog Food". All About Dog Food. Retrieved November 7, 2023.  https://www.allaboutdogfood.co.uk/dog-food-ingredients/0121/phosphoric-acid