Advance Dog Food Review -
The Complete Analysis
Our #1 Pick
Looking for the best dog food in Australia that doesn’t skimp on nutrition? Then check out our dog food review and make an educated decision.
In our Advance dog food review, we examine 5 main features: taste, ingredients list, protein content, additives, variety and price; everything you need to know to decide whether or not you should try it out.
Advance Dog Food Review
Advance Dog Food Review
Most non-fussy dogs enjoy the taste of this brand. Owners, however, complain that the smell is a bit strong for their taste. In general, we don’t think this is a huge issue, given you should be storing dry dog food in an airtight storage container either way.
However, some owners report that pups with extra-sensitive tummies suffered from diarrhoea when switching from other brands. Because of it, we recommend slowly introducing any new food to give your dog’s GI the best chance at making the switch.
Since this is otherwise a good option and most dogs enjoy the taste without showing a negative reaction, we recommend you try it.
Advance has short ingredient lists for most of their recipes, making it a great option for dogs with sensitivities. The shorter list makes it easier to know beforehand whether or not your pup will tolerate it or not. However, this simplicity comes at a cost, since Advance doesn’t add many extra goodies that are nowadays common in other dog foods like berries, vegetables, or other exotic superfoods.
Studies even show that the antioxidants found in blueberries can result in significant improvements in cognitive function in aging dogs and help support joint and bone health for active dogs. – American Kennel Club 
The food has a balanced mix of vitamins and minerals, but since these aren’t listed on their own, they’re probably from an imported pre-mix. On the other hand, they don’t mention which antioxidants and preservatives are included in the food, so that probably hints at their artificial origins. Keep in mind not all artificial preservatives are bad, but knowing exactly what goes into your dog’s food is essential to avoid dangerous extras like sulphites.
Protein Content 4/5
In this regard, Advance is in good standing. All their recipes go above and beyond the 18% minimum crude protein recommended by the AAFCO. In fact, most recipes -except the weight loss options- have between 22% and 32% of protein, depending on the formula. That means that your dog will have an adequate protein intake to handle their nutritional needs.
PRO TIP: The AAFCO recommends a minimum of 18% crude protein in your dog’s food.
Nevertheless, keep in mind Advance tends to use meal-type animal protein. So, instead of chicken, they add chicken meal, or lamb meal instead of lamb, etc. While this isn’t a huge deal, it’s important to ensure only human-grade protein meals are used. Whether or not they use human-grade ingredients isn’t specified, and because of it we’re taking 1 star off.
In spite of it, it’s good to see they don’t inflate that protein percentage with vegetables, and the entirety of the protein comes from animal sources of different kinds.
In general, Advance’s formulas are very basic. While many dog food options nowadays include fruits, veggies and healthy extras, Advance is a simple protein + carb mix with added minerals and vitamins. Only a few recipes have extra ingredients like green lipped mussel or green tea, so you’ll have to read the ingredient list every time before purchasing.
On the other hand, some small-breed Advance recipes list Sodium Tripolyphosphate (STPP) as one of the last ingredients. STPP acts as both a preservative and an extra to keep your dog’s teeth tartar-free.
In dog food, Sodium Tripolyphosphate is also used to prevent periodontal disease because of its tensioactive properties. That means it acts like soap -and it’s in fact a common ingredient in commercial soaps- binding to the natural tartar in your dog’s teeth and limiting dental calculus.
While the American FDA considers STPP as safe in small quantities, the American National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health -a CDC division- has warned against its possible neurotoxicity and consequences for sensitive tummies.
"According to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), STPP is a suspected neurotoxin and can cause digestive distress in high enough quantities." – Consumer Freedom 
According to the National Center for Biotechnology Information, dietary administration of STPP in animals has caused a decrease iron content in bone, liver, and spleen, as well as bone depletion of calcium. However, this only happens when administered in large doses. 
While in theory STPP is a good option to limit gingivitis and preserve your dog’s food, we recommend forgoing this additive and focusing on proper oral hygiene using a toothbrush.
Because of the lack of nutritional additives, and the presence of some questionable ones in certain recipes, we’re giving Advance 2 out of 5 in this category.
When it comes to variety, Advance has plenty of options to choose from. Their food is tailored to your dog’s life stage -so puppy, adult and senior dogs- as well as breed-specific needs -like retrievers, terriers…- and their adult size. On top of this, you also have the option to choose special diets designed for dogs with dental issues, those that need a diet lower in calories or a specific extra hypoallergenic diet made for sensitive tummies.
On the other hand, Advance is also one of our top picks in our best wet dog foods roundup. They offer affordable options that are great as a treat or occasional supplementation. Because of their wide variety, we’re giving the brand 5 out of 5 stars in this category.
While this brand isn’t the cheapest available, it’s a good deal considering the ingredient quality. Of course, part of the reason why it’s relatively budget-friendly is that is doesn’t have any extra ingredients like superfoods, fruits or veggies. Since you’ll probably be supplementing your pup’s diet with other fresh goodies and spending a bit more either way, we’re taking off a star.
Advance Puppy Food Review
This review wouldn’t be complete without having a look at Advance’s puppy dog food. In this case, the selection is more limited than in their adult and senior range. However, there are enough options to tailor the food to your pup’s needs.
Advance puppy dry dog food has options for all breeds, for small breeds and for large puppies. In all cases, the only protein flavour available is chicken, except for one all-breed’s wet food made with lamb. Many owners really appreciate the extra-small kibble, particularly in the small breed puppy kibble. Perfect when your little guy is teething!
PRO TIP: Advance offers puppy dry food with an extra small kibble so your pet has an easier time chewing
In spite of the limited protein options available, the composition remains fairly good and all puppy foods have chicken meal as the first ingredient, followed by rice and maize gluten -aka corn gluten-. On top of those ingredients, their puppy food also includes colostrum. Colostrum is the earliest breast milk that comes from the mother and it’s packed with extra nutrients and probiotics to help protect the newborn. While this is probably cow’s colostrum and not dog’s, it’s still an interesting addition to their puppy recipes.
Advance Puppy Plus Review
Of course, it’s also important we do an Advance puppy plus review. While their dry kibble is simply called Advance puppy, the brand also has a 2-flavour wet food selection called Puppy Plus. This is great if you want to offer a wet treat to your pup, or if you have a fussy eater.
The ingredient list of the puppy plus wet food is nice enough: the two first ingredients are plain chicken and lamb, then you have rice. Plus, as it is canned food and meant to be eaten in a single serving, it has zero preservatives.
All in all, even though Advance might not be the best option if you want to avoid corn in your puppy’s diet, it’s otherwise a clean list and a good option for your little one.
Do Not Buy If…
After going over every detail of our advance pet food review, you might be wondering whether or not you should try it. However, even if this brand is a good option for many dogs and their owners, you might want to look at other brands if you:
Is Advance Dog Food Good? Our Verdict
In general, it’s a good option for limited budgets. While it is manufactured by the same corporation in charge of Royal Canin and Optimum, it has a better ingredient list. However, they don’t offer grain-free options, which may be a deal-breaker for many owners.
While we think Advance’s composition is fairly simple, go for it if you can’t afford more expensive ones. Nevertheless, if you can splurge on better brands, go ahead. Nowadays there are more options that also offer extra goodies, superfoods, fruit and veggies right in the kibble. If not, then supplement our dog’s diet on your own.
Want to read more dog food brand reviews? Check out the below:
- National Center for Biotechnology Information (2020). PubChem Compound Summary for CID 24455, Sodium tripolyphosphate. Retrieved October 5, 2020 from https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/Sodium-tripolyphosphate.
- Sodium Tripolyphosphate. Ingredient guide, Consumer Freedom. https://wellness.consumerfreedom.com/ingredient/sodium-tripolyphosphate/
- Can My Dog Eat These Human Superfoods? American Kennel Club. https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/nutrition/can-my-dog-eat-these-human-superfoods/